Brian P. Murphy Wins Philadelphia Nursing Home Arbitration

During the height of pandemic-era visitation restrictions, the resident’s family faced communication barriers with the facility, receiving assurances of well-being despite their growing concerns. Upon removing their loved one, the family discovered significant pressure ulcers. Hospital staff documented the severity of these wounds the same day, providing a critical timeline for the legal proceedings.

The nursing home attempted to deflect liability by arguing the injuries occurred after the resident had left their care. To dismantle this defense, Murphy retained a geriatrician to analyze hospital records and admission photographs. The expert testimony concluded the wounds were too advanced to have formed in the brief window following the resident’s discharge. This victory highlights the necessity of immediate evidence preservation, such as clinical photographs and comprehensive medical records, when families suspect neglect in long-term care settings.